Sunday, May 25, 2014

Eden Prairie's hidden 6% tax increase

Residents give little thought to city roads...unless they have potholes, that is. Few realize that cities generally don't pay for the original construction of neighborhood roads--those are usually paid for by developers (and passed as price of a new home). Fewer still think about how those roads will be replaced when they are at the end of their useful life.

Cities usually pay for the rebuild of neighborhood roads in two ways. One way is to "specially assess" the properties in the neighborhood. This can be an unexpected (and expensive) shock to residents when its their turn, with residents commonly having to pay $7,000-$10,000 (usually over 10 years) to have their road rebuilt.

Other cities consider the cost of road reconstruction to be a city-wide burden. These cities generally use the ad valorem property tax to have everyone pay a little bit every year towards the construction of certain roads. 

Eden Prairie faced the issue a few summers back as the city decided that historical sources of funds for road reconstruction were inadequate because the city wanted about $2.5 million/year in funds dedicated to roads alone.  The city didn't like the special assessment route, presumably because that was certain to upset neighborhoods when it was their turn to pay.  The city also didn't like the idea of adding a new cost to the ad valorem property tax, as this would (by the city's own numbers) have led to a 6% annual increase in taxes for this line item alone!

So, what did the city do?  The city created a brand new fee--a franchise fee for utilities such as Xcel energy---to charge the utility for the right to have power lines under and adjacent to city roads and rights-of-way.  This avoided the need to special assess and avoided having residents get tax statements showing a healthy increase in taxes from one year to the next.

And at the public hearing in the summer in which this was passed..no one complained? Wait a second? Why didn't Xcel energy complain? After all, it was going to be assessed a "fee" for every property which received electricity from it? To the tune of over $2 million every year...

The answer is obvious---and certainly was well known to the city as it discussed this fee. Xcel energy didn't complain because it had no intention of paying the franchise fee---it simply passed this cost on to every customer it had in Eden Prairie. Don't believe me? Look at your utility bill. There is a line item for "frachsise fee" which didn't exist four years ago. So, contrary to the talking points by the city council at the public hearing...residents really did feel a bite because of this new city spending.

So, the franchise fee is being assessed upon the very same residents who otherwise would have been asked to pay the 6% tax increase. Only this way, most residents probably didn't realize what happened. And the city council can avoid telling people that they raised taxes by 6%.  The only economic downside to residents is that a franchise fee on a utility bill can't be written off on your taxes, but property taxes can be.

Good government?  You answer that question.

Friday, November 9, 2012

Dick Proops and the Budget Advisory Commission

Eden Prairie's Budget Advisory Commission was established in March of 2007.  Dick Proops was a charter member.  He was great at it---always prepared, did his homework, understood that city staff would filter some information from him.  He was dogged in his fight for the taxpayer. Sure, that could get uncomfortable at times, but that's what the job was.

BAC members were initially set to for three year terms from April of the year of their appointment through March.  This was changed to match our budget cycle so that members were appointed effective January of each year. And, terms were changed so that they were four year terms.

City policy is that after a commission member serves two full terms that they need a unanimous vote of the council to be reappointed to a third term. I generally agree with this, for after as much as 8 years (2 full 3 year terms and up to 2 years of a partial term) maybe it's time to give someone else a chance.

This policy was abused in 2010 to remove Dick from the BAC.  City Staff took the position that he had served two full terms between March of 2007 and December of 2010. They did so because during the re-alignment of the commission cycle Dick was assigned a 2-year term so that we would stagger the terms of commission members. Thus, they argued, he had served one term of 1.6 years and a second term of 2 years. 

It was outrageous. And unfair. And clearly intended to get rid of Dick.  Staff knew that Dick couldn't get a unanimous vote on the council. 

I thus made a motion, seconded by Jon Duckstad, to clarify that those who served on the BAC from March of 2007 until it was re-aligned to a calendar year basis had not served a full term on the commision. I needed three votes to pass this motion and permit Dick to continue on the BAC.  The only possible vote was Brad Aho and he wouldn't do it. He voted against the motion which would have allowed Dick another term on the BAC. 

Friday, October 26, 2012

Brad Aho is taking credit for my idea

Yesterday's Eden Prairie News included an election commentary by Aho in which he stated that he "initiated" the Budget Advisory Commission. As a city commission can only be created by an act of the city council, which requires 3 votes, Aho must have been trying to claim that the BAC was his idea, or that he championed it.

In fact, the BAC was my idea. I first raised it at a March 2005 city council meeting. I didn't have the votes to pass it, so it languished until after the 2006 elections, when Jon Duckstad joined the council.
I raised the issue at council meetings in January and February of 2007. I made the motion which created the BAC in March of 2007; Duckstad seconded the motion. Sure, Aho voted for it; but that hardly qualifies as "initiating."

Aho no more "initiated" the BAC than Al Gore invented the internet.

Indeed the only motion regarding the BAC which Aho made was the motion in February of 2011 (after Jon and I left the council) to neuter the BAC. For some reason he didn't mention that in his commentary.

Friday, March 30, 2012

worried about his job

From: Scott Neal

Sent: Monday, March 22, 2010 11:17 AM

To: Young, Philip J.

Subject: RE: Re:
 

Phil -



I feel like the position that I'm in is more complicated than you do.  I'd

like to talk with you more about it personally rather than email, if that's

possible.  I would use that time to respond to your specific points, but I'd

also like to talk about my future here.



Are you available for coffee before work on Wednesday morning?





Scott

Saturday, December 17, 2011

Regrettable, but not terminal

The MN GOP had a bad couple of days. Certainly in the media.  While I have several thoughts about that I'm just going to share an anecdote which may reveal how i feel about these issues and whether they are or should be politically career-ending.

A few years back I had a business meeting with the former chair of the state DFL party. He had then recently lost a primary election for an open congressional seat.  I was struck by how bitter he was; and that he'd reveal that bitterness to someone he had just met.  He had terrible things to say about the man who ultimately won the race (and who still holds that seat).  He further complained that the Strib wouldn't cover many of this man's alleged transgressions, including an affair with a staffer and a police call to his house due to what he described as excessive child discipline.  I took from this man's statements, although he didn't come right out and say it, that his campaign had been trying to get the Strib to cover these issues.   (There were certain other issues which the STrib had to cover about this candidate because they were public record, and quite embarassing).

I had previously assumed from watching this congressional race that the Strib handled this candidate with kid gloves.  It was still surprising to hear this from withing the DFL party. 

This exchange confirmed my belief that the Strib plays favorites.  But it also taught me that political damage can often be overcome.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

A unanimous Eden Prairie budget

Just a few random thoughts on the passage of the Eden Prairie budget.

In 2005, Ron Case introduced using the budget stabilization fund to reconcile the budget.  He still votes for doing so, but somehow gets away with criticizing others who do likewise. He is both for it and against it at the same time, and no one calls him on it. Amazing. 

I was disappointed that it passed unanimously. I thought one council member would have done something to hold the budget flat. What exactly is the average compensation package for Eden Prairie employees?  I bet it's north of $75,000, excluding pension.

Which leads me to my final thought. Has council member Aho voted against the council majority on any issue of substance this year? I honestly don't know the answer to that question; but i have a hunch.

Thursday, October 27, 2011

breakfast with Gary

I had breakfast with my friend Gary today.  I've known Gary for almost ten years but our routine of having breakfasts together began about 18 months ago.  Since then, he emails and texts me and we get together every six weeks or so.  He's been a good friend, forcing me to engage and interact even when I didn't want to.  He's done it just right--not too pushy but enough so that i'll feel bad if I blow him off. 

There's rarely an agenda for our meetings, although recently that's changed a little bit. But, one thing remains true-i always leave our meetings with a smile on my face. 

I'm an introvert by nature and not-at-all easy to engage. But, I'm grateful that Gary has put up with my bs.  Everyone needs a friend like him.

Thursday, October 20, 2011

football is a game of possessions

There are many different theories of how to win football games. My theory is pretty straightforward--football is a game of possessions.  Control the clock; don't turn the ball over; and have more possessions than the other team and you're in good shape to win.  I'm not a fan of the quick scoring fad which has infected college football. Problem is--quick scoring teams leave too much time on the clock.

Number three son's football season is coming to an end. His team lost its first play-off game because it fumbled the ball 4 times.  That's a killer, even in 4th grade football.

school board saga

A few random thoughts about the current state of affairs in the Eden Prairie school district.

First, it appears the administration is playing "hide the ball" with enrollment numbers.  Numbers are down, especially involving families whose children were to be moved as part of redistricting.  They should own it.

Second, because the "new" elementary school (Oak Point) is affiliated with the former Intermediate school which failed to make AYP, the students (including my two sons) are permitted under NCLB to transfer to another elementary school in town. I don't think that my kids would transfer. But, I was disturbed that the letter the administration sent out on this issue foreclosed a transfer to two of the four elementary schools in town (read: the two schools that parents would want to send their kids to are not allowed). I see this as kicking sand in the face of the parents.  The administration has screwed this whole thing up and they simply won't take ownership of that. Parents who want to move their kids should be able to move them to any of the four elementary schools in town.

Finally, the school board candidates.  There are two who i'll certainly vote for. Problem is, I have four votes.  Most of the candidates are trying their best to cover all the bases while actually saying nothing--i.e. they're willing to look at everything, study hard, include all stakeholders, and make a decision that is well-thought-out and the best for the district.  Gee, that's illuminating.

Monday, October 17, 2011

the lost decade

For most Americans retirement depends on compound interest.  Most of us don't have pensions to rely upon and you really can't retire upon whatever amount you put away in your 401k--you need those dollars to grow faster than the rate of inflation for a couple of decades.Then, you may perhaps have enough to retire when you reach your mid 60s. 

The last decade has been anemic, with stock returns barely keeping pace with inflation.   This is a real problem for people in their mid 40s, like me.  Those who are a decade older enjoyed most of the boom time in the 1990s and had enough money to enjoy those gravy years; most of my age peers were just starting out and didn't have enough put away to enjoy those 20% years.

Those who are now in their 30s have plenty of years ahead of them and frankly would be better off just slugging that 15% into their 401k during a stagnant stock market.  Time is on their side.

But, investors like me are running out of years for compound interest to even have a shot at doing some magic.  People may be working, and they may be earning. But, I don't think many have really done the retirement math--this is a problem that we won't be able to outrun.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Should the unemployed be a protected class?

We live in a competitive society which prefers outcomes based on merit. Accordingly, most people agree that discrimination based on grounds other than merit is wrong. But, when should government intervene and make discrimination illegal? That's a good question which isn't nearly debated enough. And, I'm not going to spend the time tonight to analyze our various civil rights laws. 

Instead just a brief comment on the current jobs proposal which the Obama administration is trying to get through Congress. For, one as-yet-not-well discussed provision of that jobs bill would make it illegal for employers to discriminate against the long-term unemployed.

People are unemployed for a variety of reasons. Some for performance-related reasons, but most not. It's a bad policy for any employer to lump the unemployed together and decide not to interview any of them for a job opening, preferring instead only those who are currently employed.  Actually, I think you could probably make the argument that an employer would find a hungrier, harder working employee among the ranks of the unemployed than among those who would need to be coaxed out of a current job.

That said, government should tread carefully when it choses to make bad conduct illegal. It might make a nice sound bite on the campaign trail, but I hope most people see this proposal for the gimic that it is.

Thursday, September 29, 2011

Don't let the facts get in the way of a good story....

The Strib recently ran both a "news" article and an op ed on the changes at Eden Prairie schools and the announced departure of our superintendent.  I found a few "facts" interesting.

The Stib continues to characterize those who opposed the re-districting as parents who wanted to avoid integrated schools.  They never reported the fact that each of Eden Prairie's previously four elementary schools had non-white populations in excess of 25%. In other words--they were integrated.  Two of my sons have moved from Cedar Ridge to the new Oak Point elementary and other than a very poor running bus system (the ride home from school now lasts almost 40 minutes) I discern no difference in the classes, at least as far as racial balance is concerned.  My boys enjoyed their classmates before and they enjoy them now.

The Strib also reported that the "achievement gap" had fallen by almost 50% over the last two years. The reporting of this fact missed the obvious conclusion---that the gap had been significantly reduced BEFORE the drastic redistricting had happened. This begs the question, the answer to which we'll never know--how much further could the gap have been reduced without causing huge disruption in the elementary schools? 

Most parents have tired of this issue. I know that I have. But, I remain convinced that the self-inflicted redistricting pain could have been avoided.

Friday, September 16, 2011

What will they do if elected?

The Eden Prairie school boundary change controversy has been in the newspaper for over a year now.  I've been following it with mild interest.  Sure, my kids were effected in that they had to change schools to the "new" elementary school in town; but, I didn't lose any sleep over that. Kids are resilient and making new friends is part of life for them.

That said, I do believe that the boundary change was a bad idea; and the the school board failed the residents of Eden Prairie not only in making the change but in how they dealt with the public about the change.  This was the classic solution in search of a problem--bussing kids all over town won't help close an achievement gap.

Some residents have vocally opposed the failed leadership of the school board.  And, a few of these voices are now running for school board. But, the question remains---what will they do if they win? Will they attempt to reverse the boundary changes?  I'm not sure that bell can be un-rung. 

If they can't do that, I at least hope that the new faces on the school board bring some leadership with them.  The school board, even those who opposed the boundary changes, simply are not strong leaders. They seem directionless and unable to oppose staff-driven suggestions. 

I really hope that changes.

Modern medicine

My second son recently had his appendix removed. This left me with a few thoughts about our health care system.

My wife initially took him to a hospital in Edina.  They saw our son in the ER pretty quickly and, after some CAT scans confirmed that he needed his appendix removed immediately, told us that he'd have to go to a different hospital because he was under 14.  I found this rather odd as we had been there over three hours by the time we received this news and were left to drive into Minneapolis in the middle of the night by ourselves.

However, I could not be more impressed with the level of care by son received at the U Children's hospital. Wonderful staff. First rate care. And, he left the hospital and returned home about 14 hours after surgery--unbelievable. And, with only three very small wounds were the incisions were made. 

Random thoughts on the Eden Prairie budget

I read in the local papers that the City has established a preliminary levy for 2012. This levy will modestly increase taxes, slightly more significantly increase spending, and establish certain new "fees" for residents to pay. A few thoughts given my recent history with city finance.

When cities talk about their budgets they prefer to speak only about levy increases--the amount of taxes that they will raise. This is an important point---don't get me wrong. But, it minimizes what citizens should really be concerned about--total spending.  Usually, spending will increase in a greater amount (and percent) than taxes. The reason for this is simple--fees and other non-tax revenue.  Cities will generate about 30% of their revenue from sources other than property taxes.  But, they rarely talk about this. Their primary talking point remains the levy, and that can be misleading.

Take this year, for example. The levy is forecast to rise by about 1%. But, total spending will increase by more than 3%, not including new "fees."  Sure, none of those numbers is huge. But, in a time in which economists fear a double dip recession and private sector unemployment remains high, maybe the city could tighten its belt a little more. I don't know many people who're making more money today than they did four years ago. But, city employees have enjoyed an increase in every year but one.  Whether money is generated by taxes or by fees it belongs to the people; and all people should be concerned with how much money the city intends to spend.

And, the city is toying with the idea of new "fees" to fund the capital improvement fund. Bad idea.  A "fee" is worse than an increase in property tax. At least property tax is deductible on your income tax return; a fee isn't. 

And, I still believe that government shouldn't pay "hide the ball"--if city leaders want to raise revenue they should raise taxes and tell people why. Don't start inventing unnecessary fees just so that you can claim that you're not raising taxes by that much.

And, if the city really needs money for its capital improvement fund it could start making some hard choices--for example, selling some of the unnecessary land that it owns.  The city bought land six years ago to build a fire station and has been trying to sell a remnant parcel to "the right buyer" ever since. Maybe if the city really needs more money it should do what a private landowner in need of cash would do--cut the price, get less picky on who the "right buyer" is and sell that piece of land.

Victory 5k

I've run the Victory races on Labor Day at least 7 times in the last decade. This year was the first time I ran the 5K instead of the 10K. But, I had a good reason for the shorter distance--i ran it with my son.  He and I had a goal of running a race together this summer and we realized in late August that we were running out of summer.

I had a lot of fun running with my son. I think he enjoyed it, too.  Now that the boys are getting older I'm looking forward to participating in activities with them, and not merely watching them. 

Monday, July 4, 2011

Running the Firecracker 10k

I ran the Excelsior 10k Firecracker race this morning. It's a nice run that I haven't done in about five years or so. I remember the last time I ran it one of the sponsors was a dentist; and, he handed our Krispy Kreme donuts at the end of the race.  I had to chuckle at the irony as I wolfed down a couple.

The highlight of today was that I convinced my 14 year old to run the 2 mile race. I'm trying to get him interested in running and this was his first road race.  I'm glad to say he enjoyed it, even though he had to wait about an hour for me to waddle over the finish line. We're going to try to find a 5k which we can run together this summer.

My boys are starting to get to the age where our interests will overlap. I'm looking forward to it.

Sunday, July 3, 2011

The Star Tribune ignores Lisa Goodman

Lisa Goodman is a Minneapolis city council member. A few years back her efforts to deny a development in her ward caused the developer to sue the city under a variety of theories.

The issue may seem boring to most people, but it is pretty important. Most of the decisions made by city councils involve land use--what can be built where.  City councils have tremendous power and discretion over these matters.

Residents and businesses have a right to expect fairness from their city. They have a right to be heard, and have their request fairly considered.

A Minneapolis developer felt he had been given an unfair shake, and sued. This isn't that rare or remarkable.

What is remarkable is that the Minnesota district court issued a scathing decision faulting Ms. Goodman for being unfair. Minneapolis appealed; and in May of this year the Court of Appeals upheld the decision against Minneapolis.

The Court of Appeals ordered that Minneapolis reconsider the development proposal becuase its original decision was tainted by Ms. Goodman. The Court held that the orginial decision was "arbitrary and capricious." 

That's pretty big news as developers rarely win development challenges. And, it is even more rare that our courts will scold an elected official.

What makes this even more interesting is what the Strib said about this decision--almost nothing.  And, its editorial board, which is a frequent critic of GOP elected officials, said absolutely nothing. I guess I shouldn't be surprised.


Friday, July 1, 2011

The media's hatred of conservative women

Sarah Palin's emails made news a few weeks ago.  Various media outlets had been waiting for years for the opportunity to sift through some 20,000 pages of emails from Ms. Palin's years as governor.  Alas, despite the dozens of reporters dispatched to remote Alaska, it appears that the emails reveal only that Ms. Palin spent a lot of time on the business of running a state.

The effort to obtain and sift through such miscellania is unprecedented in political reporting. It baffles me to this day.  An obscure state senator from Illinois vaulted to the national scene and was elected President with far less background interest by the fourth estate.

More recently, Michele Bachman is again under fire for factual misstatements in some of her stump speeches.  Sure, I guess some trivial pursuit champion somewhere knows the town that John Wayne was born in--i don't care. I would far rather hear what she has to say about raising the debt ceiling.

Moreover, politicians are known for gaffes. And, none is more prolific in this regard that Joe Biden. But, with his big grin and an "aw, shucks," all is forgiven by the yellow press despite the continued absurdity of the comments made by the man who is but one heartbeat away. 

I find it ironic that the liberal media elite so enjoys this double standard. After all, shouldn't those who attempt to own the words of "equality" and "choice" applaud the political success of women?

Surviving the Minnesota Shutdown

Today is the first day of the Minnesota state government shut down.  I'm not sure what to expect. But, both political sides having taken the matter this far, I think it will likely be a few weeks before anything changes. Politically it makes no sense to take the government to shut-down and then cave a week or ten days later. No, I think it'll be August before this matter is repaired.

Earlier this week I tried to determine whether there was anything I needed to do to prepare for the shutdown. For the most part, I concluded not. But, my tabs on my wife's car expire in July so I decided earlier this week to go on-line to the motor vehicle department and renew those tabs a few weeks early.

Imagine my surprise when I got to the website and found a note indicating that online services had been disabled in anticipation of the shut-down. The website told me that i would have to apply in person to get new tabs.

I remain puzzled by the cancellation of on-line renewal. In the first place, it seems to me that an on-line automated process would be far superior to an in-person process during a shut-down. In the second place, why would it be necessary to disable an on-line process three days BEFORE a shut-down?

My comments and questions are rhetorical.  The only logical conclusion is that the cessation of on-line tab renewal is intended to inconvenience those of us who might otherwise escape the shut-down unscathed.